The Internet had a tantrum, Valve and Bethesda gave in

Steam is a program made by Valve, the maker of Team Fortress 2, Half-Life, Left 4 Dead, and Portal. It’s a place to buy and download PC games into a library where you can play with friends, stream your games to them, unlock achievements, and even gift a game to a friend. It has become a Mecca for PC gaming. Before Steam, I wasn’t much of a PC gamer. Nintendo was all I knew. But then the infamous Steam Summer Sale happened, when games can be sold for 75% off or more. Like this past summer, I already had Skyrim for Xbox 360. But I wanted to be able to play the game with all of the cool mods and get a chance to play Skywind. Morrowind and Skyrim are both needed to play it and it just so happened both games were on sale at once.

Then I discovered the power of having mods for Skyrim. You can make this game look absolutely beautiful and have so much more depth in gear, weapons, quests, and more. If you can think of it, it’s probably a mod for Skyrim.

DBZ Overhaul Mod by Redman and Rigormortician

DBZ Overhaul Mod by Redman and Rigormortician

On April 23, Valve implemented a system to allow mod creators to charge money for their work. That sounds reasonable, right? Modders put a lot of hard work into their craft and never get any monetary compensation for it. As a consumer, I was bummed about it because I don’t like to pay for things that just yesterday, I didn’t have to pay for. The modders would only receive 25% of the revenue from the content sold. The Internet lost its collective mind.

Protest sign mod in Skyrim

Protest sign mod in Skyrim

On April 25, Gabe Newell, co-founder of Valve, hosted a Reddit AMA to answer questions and listen to concerns. Two days later, on April 27, Valve removed the pay feature from Skyrim mods on Steam. Well, that didn’t last long, now did it? So, what happened? Why didn’t this work? I can point to three things. People hate paying for things, especially after getting it for free for so long. Why all of a sudden can I not go to the well and get a bucket of water? Now I can only buy bottled water from this vending machine? The profit split with modders only getting 25% of the share and DRM or digital rights management concerns are the other two, which are more clearly explained here.

There were supporters of the paid mod system. Although the implementation was shaky, there were good ideas behind it. Some say there should simply be donations for mods if you wish to tip a modder for their hard work. But as one modder says, out of 200,000 downloads for a mod, he only received two donations, which means 0.001% of users donated. Valve claims it wanted to test this system out with Skyrim, but maybe such an old, more established mod community wasn’t the way to go. I hope they find a way to make this work, because I really feel like it could lead to some pretty fantastic mods that we as gamers would love to throw all our money at. Maybe we just needed to be dragged into it, kicking and screaming.

3 thoughts on “The Internet had a tantrum, Valve and Bethesda gave in

  1. A fourth reason would be that over time this will kill the mod community. I could never have gotten my mods to work right without help from other modders when I was first starting out and learning the ropes. Once money is involved why would you help other people out with your code? Or build up your own competition? This could possibly work, a $1 cap on price perhaps with a 50/50 split, but call me a cynic since I don’t think it will. New modders will have a hard time getting into the game.
    Keep it free, keep it for fun.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks for the comment, Shawn. I’m glad to have some insight from a real, live modder! I do want to see you guys get some reward for what you do, but I understand why it’s healthy for the community to be free. Maybe just the experience alone towards a new career is worth it?


      • A mod is your resume. That plus the fun of playing online with your own mods. I smile every time I see one of my maps being played on a server list. I’d love to get some sort of payment but I don’t see how I could of gotten started in a world of paid mods. That’s my only real objection.

        The other arguments aren’t really that valid in my opinion. You don’t own the code the game maker does. If another modder uses it that’s not really stealing. And no real modder doesn’t give credit to who helped you. I always listed them on my loading screens. You won’t last long in the community if you don’t.

        And the copyright issue isn’t really one. They could just do the same thing the music industry does with cover songs. When you perform someone elses music part of what you, or more usually the venue, pays to ASCAP goes to the original artist. So if the Star Wars mod for Sins of a Solar Empire was a paid mod then part of the money would go to the owners of Star Wars with each download.

        Paid mods could work, maybe, but how they went about it was the wrong way of doing it that’s for sure.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s